is a bad, really, really bad review for you? Cut about 4 over judgemental sentences & the last paragraph & the writer mostly has good things to say about the collection. True, if I didn't know you it might not inspire me to buy the book, but reading the piece as a whole it still sounds very worthwhile (& a little contradictory, as in "this is great, this is great, this is REALLY good, on the whole this is excellent, but it's just not all consistantly blow me away brilliant so I'm disappointed").

Anyway, glad it was only the first review to disappoint you & hope it is the last.